American
on tour in China many years ago
was distracted from his sightseeing itinerary by loud, angry shouts
which seemed to be coming from a cluster of people on a side street
in downtown Peking (now Beijing). Close investigation revealed two
coolies, face-to-face, angrily shouting invectives at each other,
surrounded by curious onlookers. After witnessing the altercation
for a moment or two, the American turned to one of the older
spectators and asked, "Why doesn’t one of them punch the other in
the mouth?" The old man recoiled in horror at what had just been
asked him. "Oh no," he replied, "each man knows that the first one
who resorts to violence will be deemed by the onlookers as being the
first one to have run out of ideas."
A marvelous story. Or should I say
parable, given that it both reiterates and illustrates a great
truth, well-expressed in an old nursery rhyme, "Sticks and stones
may break my bones, but words will never hurt me"? Clearly, it was
OK for the two coolies to call each other names and say the most
vile things about each other as long as they didn’t come to blows.
Right on, I'd say.
Now, with your permission, I’d
like to expand the reach of that story to reflect what I believe to
be a disturbing and dangerous trend in this country over the last
several decades.
You see, I submit to you that
there are now two other kinds of violence, each far more common
today than the physical kind. I call them "administrative violence"
and "social violence."
By "administrative violence" I
mean the establishment and implementation of a speech code by some
authority — e.g., a level of government, a large company, a college
campus — with violators severely dealt with.
And by "social violence" I mean
peer pressure manifested by excluding wayward folks from all normal
social activities as punishment for exercising their right of free
speech.
All in the name of "BROTHERLY
LOVE," "HARMONY," "CIVILITY," you name it.
In a pig’s eye, says I.
I think that the PC police do what
they do because they’re the ones who’ve run out of
ideas.
You know, the irony of it all is
that the PC police seem to believe that what they do is totally
consistent with the best democratic traditions of the Founding
Fathers. But from what I’ve read, those old boys didn’t seem to be
the least bit concerned about each other’s "sensitivity" all the
time they were hammering out two of the finer documents ever to see
the light of day — the Declaration of Independence and the
Constitution.
Which brings to mind the process
by which oysters produce pearls. They’ve gotta be irritated into doing
it.
And who can forget Harry Lime’s
incisive comment in The Third Man: "In Italy, for thirty years under
the Borgias, they had warfare, terror, murder, bloodshed — they
produced Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci and the Renaissance. In
Switzerland, they had brotherly love, five hundred years of
democracy and peace, and what did that produce? The cuckoo
clock."
Think about it.